27th May 2022

Confidant Classes

Competitors' very first choice

Home | LAW | Eight Rajya Sabha MPs suspended

Eight Rajya Sabha MPs suspended

Eight Rajya Sabha MPs were suspended Monday September 21 for rebellious behavior in the House the day before (September 20). The motion was approved by voice vote. The government introduced a motion calling for the suspension of Derek O’Brien (TMC), Sanjay Singh (AAP), Rajeev Satav (Congress), KK Ragesh (CPM), Syed Nazir Hussain (Congress), Ripun Boren (Congress), Dola Sen (TMC) and Elamaram Kareem (CPM). After the motion was adopted, Speaker Mr. Venkaiah Naidu called on Members to leave the Chamber. The suspended members initially refused to leave and then sat in a dharna outside Parliament. The opposition severely criticized the suspension of MPs.

What is the reason for the suspension of an MP?

The general principle is that it is the role and duty of the Speakers – Speaker of Lok Sabha and Speaker of Rajya Sabha – to maintain order so that the House can function smoothly. The suspension of the eight members comes a day after the Upper House witnessed massive scenes of rebellion from members of the protestant opposition as two farm bills passed. In order to ensure the smooth running of procedures, the president / president is empowered to force a member to withdraw from the hemicycle.

What are the rules according to which the Speaker acts?

Article number 373 of the rules of procedure and of the conduct of business states: “The Speaker, if he considers that the conduct of a deputy is seriously disorderly, may order the said deputy to withdraw immediately from the hemicycle, and any deputy who withdraws thus ordering him to leave, he must do so immediately and will remain absent for the rest of the day. “

  • To deal with a larger number of recalcitrant members, the Speaker would have to resort to rules 374 and 374A.

Rule 374 says:

“(1) The Speaker may, if he or she deems it necessary, appoint a Member who ignores the authority of the Speaker or who abuses the rules of the House by persistently and deliberately obstructing his or her business.

“(2) If a member is so appointed by the President, the President, in a motion tabled immediately, raises the question that the member (who appoints such member) be suspended from House service for a period not exceeding the remainder of the session: provided that the Chamber can, at any time, by means of a request, decide that said suspension be lifted.

“(3) A member suspended under this section shall immediately retire from the precincts of the House.”

  • Rule 374A was incorporated into the bylaw on December 5, 2001. The intention was to bypass the need to move and adopt a motion to stay.
  • According to article 374A: “(1) Notwithstanding what is contained in articles 373 and 374, in the case of a serious disorder caused by a member who enters the room well or who abuses in a persistent and deliberate manner and obstructs his or her business by shouting slogans or otherwise, said Member, after being appointed by the President, shall automatically be suspended from House service for five consecutive sessions or the remainder of the session, whichever is less: at provided that the House may, at any time when a motion is presented, decide to end the suspension.
  • “(2) When the Speaker announces the suspension under this article, the Member shall immediately withdraw from the precincts of the Chamber.”

Well, what about Rajya Sabha?

It’s very similar, with one important difference. Like the Speaker of Lok Sabha, the president of Rajya Sabha is empowered by rule number 255 of his rules to “order any deputy whose conduct is, in his opinion, extremely disorderly, to withdraw immediately” from the House.

  • However, unlike the Speaker, the Speaker of Rajya Sabha does not have the power to suspend a member. The House may, by another motion, terminate the suspension.
  • The Speaker may “appoint a member who ignores the authority of the president or who abuses the rules of the board by persistently and deliberately obstructing” business.
  • In such a situation, the House may adopt a motion suspending the member from House service for a period not exceeding the remainder of the session.
  • On Monday, Speaker Venkaiah Naidu suspended the eight opposition MPs. He said he was “deeply hurt” by what happened in the House on September 20.
  • “All social distancing and Covid protocols have been violated. Whatever happens, he defied logic. It was a bad day for Rajya Sabha. The Vice President (Harivansh) was physically threatened. He was concerned about his physical well-being. “

Is the suspension of a deputy a common practice in Parliament?

  • It is a strong action, but it is not uncommon. On March 5 of this year, seven members of Congress: Gaurav Gogoi (Kaliabor), TN Prathapan (Thrissur), Dean Kuriakose (Idukki), Rajmohan Unnithan (Kasaragod), Manickam Tagore (Virudhunagar), Benny Behanan (Chalakudy) and Gurjeet. Singh Aujla (Amritsar): They were suspended from Lok Sabha during the budget session of Parliament.
  • In November 2019, President Om Birla suspended two members of Congress.
  • In January 2019, Birla’s predecessor as President Sumitra Mahajan suspended a total of 45 MPs from the TDP and AIADMK after continuously interrupting debates for days.
  • On February 13, 2014, President Meira Kumar suspended 18 Andhra Pradesh MPs (indivisible) following chaos in the House. The suspended deputies supported or opposed the creation of the separate state of Telangana.
  • Prior to that, on September 2, 2014, nine members were suspended for five days.
  • On August 23, 2013, 12 members were suspended for five days.
  • And on April 24, 2012, eight members were suspended for four days.
  • On March 15, 1989, when Rajiv Gandhi was Prime Minister, no less than 63 members were suspended from Lok Sabha for three days.

Isn’t the exclusion of an elected representative of the people an extreme measure to be taken to curb rebellious behavior?

  • Members of the opposition accused the government of “killing democracy”. Each instance of suspension of a deputy provokes strong statements from both sides.
  • In general, a balance must be found. There is no doubt that the application of the supreme authority of the president is essential for the correct development of the procedure. However, it must be remembered that the President’s job is to lead the House, not dominate it.
  • The solution to rebellious behavior must be long-term and in line with democratic values. A previous president had ordered television cameras to focus on protesters, so that people could see for themselves how their representatives behaved in the House.
  • In the present case, however, the opposition accused the president of having interrupted the television broadcast of the debates in Rajya Sabha.
  • What cannot be denied is that the actions of the president / president are often dictated more by opportunism and the position of the party to which they belong than by rules and principles.
  • Thus, the ruling party at the time invariably insisted on maintaining discipline, just as the opposition insisted on its right to protest. And their positions change when their roles change.
MHT CET 2022 | Application Form, Exam Dates Revised

MHT CET 2022 | Application Form, Exam Dates Revised

Maharashtra Higher and Technical Education Minister Uday Samant announced on April 21 (Thursday) that Maharashtra CET 2022 will now be…
Read More
How to prepare for CLAT 2022

How to prepare for CLAT 2022

The Common Law Admission Test (CLAT) is an all-India entrance examination, conducted on rotation by 22 National Law Universities (NLU)…
Read More
QS World University Rankings by Subject 2022

QS World University Rankings by Subject 2022

Take a look at the top 10 colleges in the QS World University Rankings by Subject 2022. QS Quacquarelli Symonds,…
Read More
Study Abroad | UK

Study Abroad | UK

The UNITED KINGDOM (UK) has a long tradition of academic excellence. This year’s QS World University Rankings has the best…
Read More
How to prepare CUET 2022

How to prepare CUET 2022

How to prepare CUET 2022 The government has recommended that the Common Universities Entrance Test (CUET) be carried out. There…
Read More
UGC allows students to follow two full-time university programs simultaneously

UGC allows students to follow two full-time university programs simultaneously

UGC has announced guidelines for students to earn two degrees simultaneously in physical, online, or combined online mode with NEP…
Read More
DU Admission Policy

DU Admission Policy

DU Admission Policy Announced Delhi University (DU) Vice-Chancellor Yogesh Singh released the university’s admission policy under the Common University Entrance…
Read More
More than 12 lakh of candidates registered for UGC-NET 2021: NTA

More than 12 lakh of candidates registered for UGC-NET 2021: NTA

The exam on November 20 was successfully conducted in 177 cities and 338 centers in two shifts of 3 hours…
Read More
Each additional year of education increases a person’s average income by approximately 6.7% in India | study

Each additional year of education increases a person’s average income by approximately 6.7% in India | study

The study also found that each rupee invested in completing school studies is expected to generate an economic benefit of…
Read More
Public school enrollment increased by 5 percentage points in pandemic year | ASER survey 2021

Public school enrollment increased by 5 percentage points in pandemic year | ASER survey 2021

The report points out that the increase in public school enrollment is almost uniform across all age groups and levels….
Read More
error

Enjoy this? Please spread the word :)