31st July 2021

Confidant Classes

Competitors' very first choice

Home | Analysis | US sanctions against ICC officials

US sanctions against ICC officials

US sanctions against ICC officials are seen as a setback for multilateralism

  • is rare for a court to deliver justice when the sanction ends. However, in a statement this week, the United States announced sanctions, including asset freezes and visa bans, against two officials of the in The Hague.
  • Those responsible were ICC prosecutor Fatou Bensouda, and the head of the ICC’s Competence, Complements and Cooperation Division, Phakiso Mochochok (who was punished for materially assisting prosecutor Bensouda), for an investigation on alleged war crimes, by US forces and the Central Intelligence Agency, (CIA) in Afghanistan since 2003.
  • In announcing the decision, US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo called the ICC “a completely broken and corrupt institution” and threatened that the United States would “not tolerate illegitimate attempts [of the ICC] to bring Americans to its jurisdiction.”
  • “In particular, Mr. Pompeo pointed out that the United States had never ratified the “Rome Statute,” which created the ICC in 1998 and did not was therefore not subject to its decisions.
  • The investigation Ms. Bensouda opened in 2017 requested authorization to investigate war crimes, extrajudicial killings, torture and attacks against civilians by the Taliban, Afghan forces, US forces and other international military personnel stationed in Afghanistan after the fall of the Taliban.
  • In her pre-trial presentations, Ms. Bensouda said there were “reasonable grounds to believe that, since May 2003, members of the US military and the CIA have committed war crimes of torture and cruel treatment, to personal dignity and rape and other forms of sexual violence in accordance with a policy approved by US authorities ” , adding that the findings were based on the findings of the and Department of Defense committees over the years.

Blow to world order: the US decision has been criticized by the UN, the EU, 10 members of the UN Security Council, including the UK and , as well as several international human rights agencies man, all of whom have called for sanctions to invest.

  • They say the US action has been a setback for the rules-based multilateral order, and the move to sanction anyone who assists the ICC will discourage victims of violence in Afghanistan from speaking out.
  • Some have pointed out that unilateral US sanctions would encourage other regimes accused of war crimes to disobey ICC rulings.
  • The Rome Statute has been signed by 139 countries and 123 have ratified it through their parliaments and internal processes. Although the United States was part of the founding movement to build the ICC to try genocide and war crimes cases, especially after the failure of the courts in Rwanda, it decided not to ratify the statute in 2002 Countries like Russia, China and India, however, have never been in favor of the Rome Statute or the ICC, and they have never signed on.
  • For India, the decision was based on a number of principles. For starters, the ICC is a criminal jurisdiction, unlike the International Court of Justice (which rules in civil matters), and it claims the right to pursue cases against countries that are not even signatories.
  • India said the Statute gives the UN Security Council a role in terms that violate international law by granting the power to refer cases to the ICC, the power to block such referrals and the power to ‘Binding non-state parties.’ Former Indian UN envoy Asoke Mukerji about these decisions, explaining that India was basing its objections on the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties.
  • India also opposed the omission of cross-border terrorism, the use of nuclear weapons and weapons of mass destruction in areas where the ICC would open its investigations.
  • While India and other countries not signatories share US concerns about the ICC, US action is seen as yet another blow to multilateralism.
  • In the last few years, the Trump administration has walked out of several UN agencies and international agreements, including Human Rights Council, UNESCO, the Paris climate change agreement and the Iran nuclear accord.
  • Particularly at a time the U.S. accuses China of disregarding international norms in the South China Sea and other areas, and of human rights violations in Xinjiang and Tibet, the U.S.’s pushback over the ICC’s case in Afghanistan seems counterproductive.
Judiciary FAQ’s Download

Judiciary FAQ’s Download

WWW.CONFIDANTCLASSES.IN-1Download
Read More
Daily NEWS Summary | 30-07-2021

Daily NEWS Summary | 30-07-2021

College Cut-off will skyrocket, 70,004 CBSE class 12 students exceed 95% Daily NEWS Summary | 30-07-2021; The number of Central…
Read More
Careers after Class  12th | Commerce

Careers after Class 12th | Commerce

Careers after the 12th are the most important decisions in life. There are many career options available after Class 12…
Read More
Daily NEWS Summary | 29-07-2021

Daily NEWS Summary | 29-07-2021

Supreme Court urged to take cognizance of alleged murder of Jharkhand Additional District Judge Daily NEWS Summary | 29-07-2021; The…
Read More
The National Institutes Of Food Technology, Entrepreneurship And Management Bill, 2021

The National Institutes Of Food Technology, Entrepreneurship And Management Bill, 2021

Parliament has passed National Institutes of Food Technology, Entrepreneurship and Management Bill 2021, with this NIFTEM in Haryana and the…
Read More
Daily NEWS Summary | 28-07-2021

Daily NEWS Summary | 28-07-2021

Parliamentary panel not authorized to discuss Pegasus Daily NEWS Summary | 28-07-2021; In total failure, the Standing Committee on Information…
Read More
Daily NEWS Summary | 27-07-2021

Daily NEWS Summary | 27-07-2021

Basavaraj Bommai will be the new Chief Minister of Karnataka Daily NEWS Summary | 27-07-2021; Basavaraj Bommai, 61, was elected…
Read More
Daily NEWS Summary | 26-07-2021

Daily NEWS Summary | 26-07-2021

Yediyurappa announces his resignation as Chief Minister of Karnataka Daily NEWS Summary | 26-07-2021; B S Yediyurappa announced his resignation…
Read More
Daily NEWS Summary | 25-07-2021

Daily NEWS Summary | 25-07-2021

Pegasus issue: Rajya Sabha MP moves SC in court-supervised investigation Daily NEWS Summary | 25-07-2021; John Brittas, a member of…
Read More
Daily NEWS Summary | 24-07-2021

Daily NEWS Summary | 24-07-2021

India’s first medal at the Tokyo Olympics, courtesy of Daily NEWS Summary | 24-07-2021; India won its first…
Read More
Daily NEWS Summary | 23-07-2021

Daily NEWS Summary | 23-07-2021

Parliament does not function for the fourth consecutive day Daily NEWS Summary | 23-07-2021; Parliament did not function for the…
Read More
error

Enjoy this? Please spread the word :)